Search for: All records

In this paper, we describe and reflect upon the development of critical consciousness and workplace democracy within an experimental workplace called DataWorks. Through DataWorks, we hire adults from communities historically minoritized in computing education and data careers, and train them in entry-level data skills developed through work on client projects. In this process, workers gain a range of skills. Some of these skills are technical, such as programming for data analysis; some are managerial, such as scoping and bidding projects; others are social, perhaps even political, such as the ability to say No to projects. In what follows, we describe a workshop series developed to build the workers' critical literacy and consciousness about their data work, specifically regarding the use of data in machine learning systems. After that, we describe a data project the workers questioned and resisted because they determined the work to be harmful. In that process, they demonstrated and enacted a critical consciousness towards data and machine learning. Reflecting on this enactment of data-focused critical consciousness, we identify themes that characterize a democratic workplace, describe the work of designing for organizational action and institutional relations, and discuss how worker and researcher positionality affects this work. In doing so, we argue for enabling workers to resist and refuse harmful data work and challenge the standard power structures of academic research and data work. 

While much computing education research focuses on formal K-12 and undergraduate CS education, a growing body of work is exploring alternative pathways to computing careers [7, 16], alternative outcomes for computing education [15], and adult learning in workplace communities [9, 13]. Within this context, we are studying novice-friendly computational work as a pathway to computing careers. Novice-friendly computational work is a phrase we use to describe computing activities that have a low barrier to entry, are used in authentic contexts outside formal CS spaces, and are legitimate computational activities, e.g., data work [13], web design [5], and Salesforce CRM [9]. Learning through authentic work practices is a promising pathway to computing careers because it poses lower financial and findability barriers than coding bootcamps [14] and online courses [4]. However, gatekeeping culture in computing deems novice-friendly tools like Excel, HTML/CSS, and JSON distinct from “real” programming [12]. Further, novice workers may not be considered legitimate peripheral members of computing communities of practice despite engaging in legitimate computational work [6, 11].